California Surrogacy Myths: What Potential Surrogates Should Know
September 11, 2025 by Frank Golden
If you’ve been thinking about becoming a Surrogate in California, you’ve probably heard some confusing information. Maybe a friend shared a story that didn’t sound quite right. Or you saw something on social media that made you nervous.
You’re not alone! California surrogacy myths are everywhere. They spread through movies, TV shows, and well-meaning but misinformed conversations. The problem is that these myths can stop amazing women from pursuing something truly meaningful.
This article will separate fact from fiction. We’ll tackle the most common misconceptions head-on. By the end, you’ll have the clarity you need to make an informed decision about your surrogacy journey.
Table of Contents
- Why There Are So Many Surrogacy Myths
- Myth #1: Surrogates Are Giving Up Their Own Baby
- Myth #2: Surrogacy Is Unsafe for Women
- Myth #3: Surrogates Aren’t Protected Legally in California
- Myth #4: Surrogacy Is Only About the Money
- Myth #5: Surrogates Lose Control Over Their Bodies
- Myth #6: Surrogates Are Pressured or Taken Advantage Of
- Myth #7: Surrogacy Is Emotionally Harmful
- How Ethical Agencies Help Prevent These Myths From Becoming Reality
- Frequently Asked Questions About California Surrogacy Myths
- Making an Informed Decision About Surrogacy in California
Why There Are So Many Surrogacy Myths
Surrogacy myths exist for several reasons. Let’s break them down!
Media portrayals play a big role. Movies and TV shows often dramatize surrogacy for entertainment. They show custody battles, emotional breakdowns, and worst-case scenarios. These stories make for good television, but they don’t reflect reality.
Social media spreads misinformation quickly. One person shares an inaccurate post, and suddenly thousands see it. Without fact-checking, myths gain momentum fast.
Confusion between surrogacy types causes problems too. Many people don’t know the difference between traditional and gestational surrogacy. In California, surrogacy is exclusively gestational. This means the Surrogate has no genetic connection to the baby she carries.
California law is often misunderstood. Some people assume all states treat surrogacy the same way. They don’t! California has some of the strongest protections for Surrogates in the entire country. Understanding California surrogacy laws helps clear up many misconceptions.
The good news? Once you have accurate information, these myths lose their power!
Myth #1: Surrogates Are Giving Up Their Own Baby
The Truth: In gestational surrogacy, the Surrogate has absolutely no biological connection to the baby.
This is perhaps the most common myth out there. It comes from confusion about how modern surrogacy actually works.
Here’s what really happens. An embryo is created using eggs and sperm from the Intended Parents or donors. That embryo is then transferred to the Surrogate’s uterus. The Surrogate provides a nurturing environment for the baby to grow. But genetically? The baby belongs to the Intended Parents.
Think of it this way. You’re not giving up anything that was ever yours. You’re helping someone else’s child enter the world safely.
California law recognizes this distinction clearly. Pre-birth orders establish the Intended Parents as the legal parents before delivery even happens. There’s no ambiguity about who the baby belongs to.
Myth #2: Surrogacy Is Unsafe for Women
The Truth: Surrogacy involves rigorous medical screening to protect Surrogate health and safety.
Some people worry that surrogacy puts women at unnecessary risk. This concern is understandable but misguided.
The reality? Only women who have already had healthy pregnancies qualify to become Surrogates. According to the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), candidates must demonstrate they can carry a pregnancy safely.
Before approval, potential Surrogates undergo extensive medical evaluations. These include physical exams, lab testing, and detailed medical history reviews. The goal is to identify any health concerns before pregnancy begins.
California fertility clinics follow strict guidelines. They won’t approve a Surrogate unless she meets specific health criteria. This protects both the Surrogate and the baby.
The CDC emphasizes the importance of prenatal care for all pregnancies. Surrogates receive even more monitoring than typical pregnancies. You’ll have a dedicated medical team watching over you every step of the way.
Check out our California Surrogate requirements to learn more about health qualifications!
Myth #3: Surrogates Aren’t Protected Legally in California
The Truth: California offers some of the strongest legal protections for Surrogates in the nation.
This myth couldn’t be further from reality! California is considered a “gold standard” state for surrogacy. The legal framework here specifically protects Surrogate rights.
Every Surrogate gets her own independent attorney. This lawyer works exclusively for you, not the Intended Parents. Your attorney reviews the surrogacy contract and ensures your interests are protected.
The legal process begins only after medical clearance. This means you’ll understand all legal aspects before any medical procedures start. Nothing moves forward until you’re comfortable with the agreement.
Pre-birth orders establish parental rights before delivery. The Intended Parents’ names go directly on the birth certificate. There’s no confusion, no custody concerns, and no legal gray areas.
California courts consistently uphold surrogacy agreements. Your rights and your compensation are legally protected throughout the entire journey.
Myth #4: Surrogacy Is Only About the Money
The Truth: Compensation supports Surrogates through a demanding process, but motivation runs much deeper.
Yes, Surrogates receive compensation. And that’s completely appropriate! Carrying a pregnancy requires significant physical, emotional, and time commitments.
But here’s what the myth gets wrong. Most Surrogates aren’t motivated primarily by money. They’re driven by something far more meaningful.
Many Surrogates have personal connections to infertility. Perhaps a sister struggled to conceive. Or a friend experienced pregnancy loss. These experiences create deep empathy for families who need help.
Other Surrogates simply love being pregnant! They’ve had wonderful pregnancy experiences and want to share that gift with others.
California Surrogate compensation reflects the real commitment involved. It covers time away from work, childcare needs, and physical demands. Compensation isn’t exploitation. It’s recognition of a Surrogate’s dedication.
At Golden Surrogacy, Founder Frank Golden leads the team and guides every Surrogate as family. The focus is always on your well-being, not just completing a transaction.
Myth #5: Surrogates Lose Control Over Their Bodies
The Truth: Surrogates retain medical decision-making rights throughout pregnancy.
This fear is completely understandable. Your body is yours, and you should never feel like you’ve lost control over it.
The good news? California law protects your bodily autonomy. Surrogacy contracts cannot override your fundamental medical rights. You always have the final say on decisions affecting your health.
During pregnancy, you’ll work with your OB-GYN to make appropriate medical choices. The Intended Parents can share preferences, but medical decisions remain between you and your doctor.
Ethical surrogacy agreements are built on mutual respect. They outline expectations clearly while honoring your autonomy. Nothing in a well-crafted contract takes away your right to make decisions about your own body.
Myth #6: Surrogates Are Pressured or Taken Advantage Of
The Truth: Ethical screening processes ensure Surrogates enter the journey freely and with full understanding.
This myth assumes Surrogates are vulnerable people being manipulated. That’s simply not accurate.
Psychological screening is required for all potential Surrogates. Licensed mental health professionals evaluate emotional readiness. They ensure candidates understand exactly what they’re committing to.
You can decline a match at any point. If something doesn’t feel right, you have every right to say no. Ethical agencies never pressure Surrogates to proceed against their instincts.
Background checks, medical evaluations, and psychological assessments all work together. They create a foundation of trust and informed consent. Only women who genuinely want to help build families move forward.
The California Surrogacy timeline includes multiple checkpoints. At each stage, you have opportunities to ask questions and express concerns.
Myth #7: Surrogacy Is Emotionally Harmful
The Truth: With proper preparation and support, most Surrogates describe the experience as deeply fulfilling.
Emotions are part of any pregnancy journey. But “emotionally harmful”? That’s not what Surrogates typically report.
Psychological screening helps identify women who are emotionally prepared. Candidates who might struggle with the experience are compassionately redirected. This protects everyone involved.
Support systems make a huge difference! At Golden Surrogacy, a dedicated Care Team supports Surrogates throughout the entire journey. The Agency Director is available via phone, text, and email whenever you need guidance.
Many Surrogates form meaningful connections with Intended Parents. These relationships often continue long after delivery. Rather than feeling loss, Surrogates frequently describe feeling profound joy and purpose.
Post-birth support helps with emotional transition. You won’t be alone in processing your feelings. Professional resources are available to help you celebrate what you’ve accomplished.
How Ethical Agencies Help Prevent These Myths From Becoming Reality
Working with the right agency makes all the difference! Ethical agencies prioritize Surrogate education and protection.
Education before commitment. You’ll learn everything about the surrogacy process before making any decisions. Questions are welcomed and answered thoroughly.
Transparent communication. No surprises, no hidden expectations. Everything is discussed openly from day one.
Strong screening standards. Medical evaluations, psychological assessments, and background checks protect everyone. In-person screening must align with menstrual cycle timing to ensure accuracy.
Ongoing advocacy. Your agency represents your interests throughout the journey. During the second trimester, birthrights and hospital coordination commence. You’ll know exactly what to expect at every stage.
Golden Surrogacy maintains these ethical standards because Surrogates deserve nothing less!
Frequently Asked Questions About California Surrogacy Myths
Can a Surrogate keep the baby?
No. In gestational surrogacy, the Surrogate has no genetic connection to the baby. California law establishes the Intended Parents as legal parents before birth. Pre-birth orders ensure clear parental rights.
Is surrogacy risky?
All pregnancies carry some risk. However, Surrogates undergo extensive medical screening to ensure they can carry safely. Only women with healthy pregnancy histories qualify. Medical monitoring throughout pregnancy adds extra protection.
Are Surrogates protected by California law?
Absolutely! California offers some of the strongest Surrogate protections in the country. Every Surrogate receives independent legal representation. Contracts are legally enforceable, and parental rights are clearly established.
Is surrogacy emotionally difficult?
Experiences vary, and education is key to informed decision-making. Psychological screening ensures candidates are emotionally prepared. Support systems help Surrogates navigate the journey successfully. Most describe the experience as rewarding rather than harmful.
Making an Informed Decision About Surrogacy in California
You’ve now seen the truth behind common California surrogacy myths. Facts replace fear when you have accurate information!
Here’s what matters most. You deserve to make decisions based on reality, not misconceptions. Whether surrogacy is right for you is a personal choice. Only you can determine if this path aligns with your values and goals.
Take your time! There’s no rush. Continue learning, ask questions, and trust your instincts.
When you feel ready to explore further, Golden Surrogacy is here to help. Our team provides honest information without pressure. We believe educated Surrogates make the best decisions for themselves and the families they help create.
Ready to learn more? Visit our Become a Surrogate page to take the next step at your own pace!
